Lydd Playground Swing Failures Caused by Vandalism, Says Safety Report

A series of mysterious swing failures at The Rype Play Area in Lydd has been traced to deliberate misuse rather than any manufacturing defect, according to a new report by a playground safety expert. The report, presented to Lydd Town Council and dated 26 February 2025, details how three swing fixings – the metal connectors attaching the swings to their frame – broke within a short span on different swings. An investigation by David Yearley, Head of Play Safety at The Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents (RoSPA), concludes that the equipment failed under unnatural strain, likely caused by intentional improper use.

Repeated Breakages Spur Investigation

Residents and council officials grew concerned after three separate swing connectors failed in quick succession at The Rype play area. The incidents involved two standard flat swings and one dual “Tango” swing (a face-to-face adult-and-toddler swing), all located on the popular Rype playground. According to Yearley’s report, “There have been three failures of fixings on swings at The Rype within a relatively short period of time, and on different swings”. In other words, multiple swings suffered breakages around the same time, prompting the council to seek expert help to find out why.

Lydd Town Council commissioned David Yearley – a leading playground safety specialist from RoSPA Play Safety – to investigate the cause of the failures. Yearley visited the site on 3 February 2025 to examine the playground and collected the broken swing components for analysis. In his report, Yearley notes he was asked “to view the equipment in question and give an opinion on the causes of failure”. He reviewed the damaged parts back at the Town Council offices and inspected the swing set structure on-site, looking for any clues that could explain why the metal connectors had snapped.

What Broke and How It Happened

The failures all occurred at the swing-to-frame connection point – specifically the metal coupling that links the swing’s chains to the top bar of the frame. Yearley’s report identifies two different types of swing fixings involved in the incidents. Two of the broken connectors were from the flat-seat swings, which use a metal shackle to attach the seat chains to the frame; the third was from the special tandem “Tango” swing, which uses a different connector design. In each case, the metal at the top of the swing assembly gave way.

According to the report’s description, the flat swing connectors showed signs of heavy wear and twisting before ultimately snapping. The metal had been worn down and twisted at the point of failure, suggesting it was subjected to sustained stress beyond normal swinging. In contrast, the tandem swing’s connector broke off cleanly, with the remaining piece bent on the side opposite the break. This clean snap hinted at a sudden extreme force being applied. Notably, Yearley found no evidence of any manufacturing flaw in any of the broken parts – the fractures appeared to result from mechanical stress rather than defective metal.

Photographs included in the report provided further clues. One image showed deep gouge marks on the top of a swing’s pivot bolt – damage that would not occur under ordinary use. This scoring indicated that users had been wrapping the swing’s chains over the top bar of the frame. Many children are known to flip or twist swing seats over the top bar to shorten the chains, but doing so can put abnormal strain on the equipment. In this case, such behavior appears to have been a key factor in the metal fatigue and breakage. Yearley observed that the paint on the top beam was scuffed, and the holes in the metal hangers were slightly elongated from force, further evidence that the swings had been pulled or twisted far beyond their normal range.

Expert Concludes “Deliberate Misuse” by Users

After examining the physical evidence, Yearley’s conclusions are blunt. In his professional opinion, these swing fixings did not fail on their own – they were broken by people. The report states that the connectors likely failed due to “deliberate and concerted efforts to induce failure by users”. In simpler terms, the swings were apparently misused on purpose until they snapped. Yearley notes that under normal play conditions, such hardware should not break at all. He wrote that in 20 years of inspecting playgrounds, he could “find no previous instance in our records where this type of swing fixing has failed in the way seen in the two failures at The Rype”.

To double-check whether the equipment was at fault, Yearley even reached out to the manufacturer of the swing units, HAGS. HAGS’s Technical Manager, Andy Yates, told him that he had “not seen such a failure in 20 years” of using this swing design. This long track record with no similar incidents strongly supports the report’s conclusion that something unusual – likely misuse or vandalism – caused the Lydd breakages. No design or material defect was found in the failed parts. In fact, Yearley emphasizes that the broken connectors were built to meet rigorous safety standards (BS EN 1176-1:2017+A1:2023 and EN 1176-2:2017) and had “proven themselves over a period of 20 years to withstand normal wear and tear”. In other words, the equipment is considered fit for purpose and would not have failed without some extreme external force.

Yearley’s analysis suggests that excessive loading or intentional abuse was the only plausible cause. He described one failure as likely resulting from “overloading by a deliberate…effort to induce failure” when the swing was in use. Given the pattern of damage – twisted metal, scored paint, and multiple breakages – the implication is that individuals were intentionally subjecting the swings to stresses far beyond normal play, possibly as an act of mischief or vandalism. By the report’s conclusion, “the fixings…were caused by misuse” in all cases.

Safety Standards and Reassurances

While the findings are troubling for the community, they also carry a reassuring message: the playground equipment itself is sound. The fact that the swing fixings meet modern European safety standards and have a decades-long history of safe use elsewhere means local families can be confident in the equipment’s quality. The problem, according to the expert, is not a faulty design but unsafe behavior. The report effectively clears the manufacturer and the hardware of blame. HAGS’s confirmation of no prior failures backs this up, indicating that what happened at The Rype is an outlier caused by unusual use.

Yearley’s report underscores that proper use and supervision are key to playground safety. Even the best-designed swings cannot endure intentional misuse indefinitely. Fortunately, the investigation did not find any systemic risk to other equipment in The Rype play area – only the broken connectors needed replacing, and those have known safety specifications. The council can therefore focus on preventing a repeat of such incidents rather than undertaking any large-scale equipment overhaul.

Council Response and Next Steps

Lydd Town Council welcomed the expert findings, as they shed light on a perplexing issue that had concerned residents. With misuse identified as the cause, the council’s challenge now is to deter this behavior. Town officials have not yet announced specific measures, but greater supervision, community awareness, or signage could be considered to discourage people from abusing the swings. Since the report concludes the equipment is fundamentally safe when used correctly, any solution will likely center on educating and monitoring playground users rather than engineering fixes.

The council has already replaced or repaired the damaged swing fixings, ensuring the playground is safe to use going forward. Parents and children returning to The Rype Play Area can do so with the knowledge that the swings are structurally sound. However, the community is urged to treat the facilities with care. “I shall be pleased to engage with the report’s commissioning officer to ensure it is clearly understood,” Yearley noted in closing, indicating his willingness to help the council interpret the findings. Town leaders are now armed with a clear explanation for the swing failures – and a reminder that maintaining a safe play environment is a responsibility shared by everyone who uses it.

The Shepway Vox Team

Not Owned By Hedgefunds or Barons