Benefits Fraud Gets the Headlines — Local Government Fraud Is Estimated at £6.7bn

Benefit fraud gets plenty of attention. But figures in the latest Annual Fraud Indicator show that estimated fraud against local government is running at almost the same cash value — and, measured against the amount being spent, at a higher rate.

Although the report was published in 2026, the individual benefits and local-government tables used in this article are explicitly labelled 2025.

Crowe estimates £7.173 billion of fraud across benefits and tax credits. That is out of total expenditure of £326.36bn, giving an estimated fraud rate of 2.20%.

Now look at local government.

Crowe estimates £6.692 billion of fraud against £245.15bn of local-government expenditure. That works out at 2.73%.

So while the cash difference between the two fraud estimates is only £481 million, something even more striking happens when we compare fraud with the amount of money being spent.

Benefits and tax credits: 2.20%.

Local government: 2.73%.

Put simply, Crowe’s estimated fraud rate against local-government spending is about 24% higher than its rate for benefits and tax credits.

And the £6.692bn local-government figure does not include benefit fraud.

It is made up of an estimated £5.372bn in procurement fraud, £510m in payroll fraud, £419m involving public-service pensions, £173m in housing-tenancy fraud, £169m in grant fraud and £48m involving the Blue Badge scheme.

One figure dwarfs everything else: procurement.

Councils spend huge sums buying goods and services from outside organisations. That can include everything from construction and IT systems to social-care provision, professional services, equipment and everyday supplies.

Crowe puts local-government procurement spending at £140.049bn and applies an estimated fraud-loss rate of 3.84%. That produces an estimated £5.372bn of procurement fraud alone.

That means procurement accounts for about four-fifths of Crowe’s entire local-government fraud estimate.

Crowe gives examples of what procurement fraud can look like: duplicate invoices, extra items being added to bills, goods being ordered and kept, bank-account details being changed and fake suppliers being created. The report also discusses bribery and corruption risks connected with contracts.

But there is an important warning before anybody reads £6.692bn as though investigators have physically uncovered that exact amount.

They haven’t.

Much of this is estimated fraud, not money already found in individual proven cases.

Crowe grades its figures according to the strength of the evidence behind them. Procurement and payroll are classed as Silver estimates. In simple terms, researchers take fraud-loss rates found through measurement work and apply those percentages across much larger areas of spending. Crowe itself says much of its local-government analysis relies on lower-quality data than some other parts of the report.

The report explains that its Silver estimates are designed to expose fraud which may otherwise remain hidden. For procurement it uses 3.84%; for payroll 0.65%. Those percentages are then applied across expenditure of that type.

So £6.692bn should not be described as £6.692bn of fraud already detected and proven by councils.

It is Crowe’s estimate of the scale of the problem.

And that distinction between an estimate, a saving, an error and actual proven fraud matters enormously — as we have already discovered here in Folkestone and Hythe.

Earlier this year, Folkestone & Hythe District Council said its investigations work had produced a financial impact of £1,266,259 across 466 cases recorded as “Fraud or Error Proven”.

But the council’s published figures did not tell residents how many of those 466 cases were fraud and how many were errors. Nor did they say how much of the £1.266m belonged to each category.

When Cllr Tim Prater, FHDC’s Cabinet Member for Finance and Governance, was asked about the difference between money claimed intentionally and money claimed unintentionally, he described intention as a “fuzzy line” which could rarely be known.

Yet FHDC’s own anti-fraud policy treats intention as important. Its policy deals with knowingly or dishonestly providing false information, or failing to disclose information, with the intention of gaining financially.

In everyday language, the distinction is straightforward.

A mistake is not automatically fraud.

There was another problem with FHDC’s £1.266m headline.

Of that total, £336,000 related to eight tenancy cases. That wasn’t £336,000 recovered from somebody. FHDC used a notional value of £42,000 for each council property returned to proper use.

Another £316,419 represented savings expected in future years from Council Tax work.

Together, those two figures came to £652,419 — 51.5% of FHDC’s £1.266m headline figure.

Those savings can have genuine value.

But they aren’t all the same thing.

A future saving isn’t money recovered today.

A notional value placed on getting a council home back isn’t the same thing as £42,000 being stolen.

And an error isn’t automatically fraud.

That is exactly why huge national fraud figures need explaining rather than simply repeating.

Crowe also makes another important limitation clear. Its £6.692bn local-government figure covers expenditure and excludes all types of income fraud. In other words, Crowe isn’t claiming £6.692bn represents every conceivable way in which councils might lose money to fraud.

Even with all those cautions, the comparison is hard to ignore.

In Crowe’s 2025 tables:

Benefits and tax credits: £326.36bn spent, £7.173bn estimated fraud, or 2.20%.

Local government: £245.15bn spent, £6.692bn estimated fraud, or 2.73%.

The difference in estimated fraud losses is just £481m.

Local government therefore has roughly £81bn less expenditure in this comparison, yet Crowe estimates its fraud losses at almost the same cash amount — and at a higher percentage of spending.

That doesn’t mean benefit fraud matters less.

It means fraud involving council contracts, payrolls, grants, pensions and other public spending deserves serious attention too.

And the Folkestone and Hythe example gives us another lesson.

Whenever a public body announces that it has lost, recovered or “saved” money through fraud work, taxpayers should be able to understand exactly what the headline number contains.

How much was actually fraud?

How much was error?

How much cash was recovered?

How much was spending prevented in future?

And how much was a notional value put on something else?

Because when Crowe is estimating £6.692 billion of fraud against local government, those aren’t minor technical distinctions.

They are the difference between a big number and understanding what that big number really means.

The Shepway Vox Team

The Velvet Voices Of Voxatiousness

About shepwayvox (2641 Articles)
Our sole motive is to inform the residents of Shepway - and beyond -as to that which is done in their name. email: shepwayvox@riseup.net

Leave a Reply